Sunday, August 14, 2011

MAP v/s DIAGRAM


An interesting debate happening on the redesign of the London Tube map by Mark Noad. In short it is about the graphic being called DIAGRAM or a MAP.

It is taking us back to basic principles of What is a Map? and What is a Diagram?

What Mr. Beck did was in a true sense a 'diagram'. He completely find a way around the Geographical reference which is not required at all in planning your trip on a metro system.

The journey planning is between start and an end point via lines through interchanges.

Visually as well - a passenger is least bothered about the relative geographical alignment and inter-relation of the various lines. Such a system is best suited for the majorly underground system of 'The Underground'.

The map also made sense by fitting in a rectangular piece of paper and use of grid made it easy to make the station names align well in a readable size on a hand map.

People are very comfortable with this 'Diagram'. They are not bothered if we call it as a map or a diagram.

What Mark Noad picked up was the word "MAP" and made it useful beyond its application for integrated Transit system. When I Say integrated - it includes people walking, cycling, interchanging from bus, taxis and other modes with the underground.

Noad very well captured the geographical reference and relation of the lines to each other.

But I guess it can be done for any similar System diagram in the world. May it be piping in a factory or a metro system.

We did the initial metro map for Delhi with reference to the geographical alignment. It makes sense as the lines are elevated. A if the map is plotted well and made visually relaxing then doing geographical alignment makes a lot sense.

Noad's map is neither incorrect not difficult to use. The reaction to Noad's map is more emotional as it directly affects a design icon. Due to the geographical alignment the texts have become smaller and eyes have to train and the reading time will increase.

I appreciate Noad's graphic as a MAP and Beck's graphic as a DIAGRAM but frankly enough there is no need to change the DIAGRAM specially in case of London. It may make make sense for multiscreen applications. but still there is a limitation of reading it and making is simple to understand.


read more at this link
http://www.fastcodesign.com/1664662/the-london-tube-map-redesigned-for-a-multiscreen-world

No comments: