Saturday, October 5, 2013

Service design - An emerging domain for design thinkers

Just remembered a statement from Pu. La. Deshpande's character sketches.
In Pune - " the Most neglected item in a shop is - a customer.."
But Pune is now changing and more customer friendly and service oriented.

Service design is an emerging area of attention which business are realising as one of the critical parameters for sustainable business and growth.
The automotive companies noticed very early on that beyond simply buying a car the experience of buying it was also important and thus companies invested hugely into developing a customer oriented ambiance at the retail touch points. Cars, Shoes, Cloths or Phones are all tangible products but consumer is now aware and critical of his experience in flying, experience in banking or even experience in hospital.
Till now all these experiences were system generated in line with back-end processes requirements, activity driven, ease of use in capturing information, compilation, reduce errors and were an evidence of a natural evolution.
e.g. A pay-in slip in the bank was designed for accommodating all the necessary information that the bank wanted a customer to fill.
The route numbers of a bus system reflected the sequence in which new routes were introduced basis needs and purely system driven.
But now this is changing. It is time these elements are seen from the point of view of a consumer and not just the service provider.
The form should not just be legible but easy to fill, the route numbers should make sense and have some rational basis the areas they serve in relation to other routes.
Design thinkers have now taken this filed where they can add a value. Service Design discipline is growing rapidly.
The fact that designers have been thinking from a users perspective while they did graphic design, product design, industrial design or user interface design. This puts them in a better position to add the user insight for delivering a service. Either you are paying a bill, using public  transport or eating out at a food joint.
Designers will definitely bring in value but cannot do it alone. In my opinion - you can design a service once but the critical part is how you are able to sustain the service levels. And this does not happen in one day. An ambiance created by interior design, colours and graphic messages added to it, streamlined communication and interaction protocal and very well designed products can stay longer and do their function for which they are designed.
According to me - a service design through design intervention if only results in creating these tangible touch points - it will have a short life. What is required is a equal participation of the stake holder who are delivering this service and making a agile, adaptable system which can respond to the changes in context, stakeholder requirements, external influences.
Service design cannot be a single time exercise. What it needs is a developing a collective culture and awareness of collective intelligence which will operate at every step through the people and systems delivering the service. New experience should be fed back to the system so that it adapts to the changes and becomes a self learning system.
It is a collaborative work by people who deliver the service, all stake holders in the system, and designers who can contribute in providing user insights and improvements through design intervention.
It should not be assumed that designers can single handedly bring the change.
Many times the people delivering the service can come out with innovative approaches to serve the customers.
Finally person sitting across the counter packing a product for you if delivers the goods to a customer with a smile and best wishes, a user is bound to come back.

I always remember a rikshwa-wala in pune who once greeted me - Good morning at 5:30am on a rainly morning. I still hope I come across this person more times.

If you want to read more -



Saturday, April 13, 2013

My first Jury Experience on other side of table.


It was a regular day in office. The phone rang. It was a call from my college inviting me as an external examiner for first year Architecture subject of Basic design. My opportunity for teaching could not workout due to my current commitments at the office.
For this request I agreed in a flash of second. There was no second thought and no explanations like “I will check my diary” and “Will let you know”, checking with my wife and family about weekend plans or anything. There was no possibility of saying no this opportunity. Being Saturday I immediately agreed and informed my wife, Manasi, who was equally thrilled as she has been my greatest support and believes that I should teach. 
For next 2 weeks there was no great preparation beyond a call with internal examiner and the person who conducted the course through the year.
I was excited. 
The day came and here I was climbing the steps of the same institute as an external jury, The same place where 22  years ago I had walked in with my father to get enrolled for studying architecture, which taught me to think differently. Here I met the greatest of minds, who taught us the basic principles of design while the interaction inside and outside class, have groomed us intellectually and philosophically.
Here we learned the mother of all arts - Architecture.
The place has hardly changed but the spirit still is the same. Though I also felt sad that it has got stuck in time and not grown in spite of having brilliant distinguished staff, alumni and a very sound and enriched tradition of teaching.
BKPS college of Architecture is actually a very strong brand which is not getting its worth. 
Basic design, the very foundation of ones awareness and developing senses towards the beginning of a lifelong quest for asking questions, learning and getting the power of creating the world around you. It is a beginning of a journey of self expression, realisation, discovery, soul searching, responsibility and the finely tuned feeling of being given the power to create and influence the world and make a difference. 
Felt nostalgic sitting in the very class which we occupied during the second year of our course. Here I was going to meet the young minds who have started the same journey I started 22 years ago.
Probably these young boys and girls were not even born at that time. I still feel young and could imagine myself sitting in the first year classroom with boys and girls walking in, on the very first day who are one of the best friends I made for my life. 
Unfortunately all our memories are sealed in different minds and mental images and not commented and liked with occasional pokes. 
Meeting all the staff and the non teaching staff who are doing their job with the same sense of dedication for years elevates my respect for them. The weathered look and the simplicity are in striking contrast to the life and work of the gems it as created through the years. They are simply doing their work and I admire them to the fullest. It's the relationship between a diamond and the diamond cutter. One occupies the limelight and the spotlight while the other is in the oblivion. 

I went through the portfolio of a student as a sample work to prepare for the jury. 
Teaching is not a secondary job. You cannot do it with your left hand. The first student walked in. I was equally anxious as the student. There was no plan of action any preconceived thought or precedence. 
My reactions were simple, spontaneous and straight. As a person I started seeing many layers in a student and his work. There was a dilemma. Should I only see what is factually on paper and in front of me or  should go few layers inside and see his personality, background and his context? My judgment should not go wrong. There was nothing right either. Basic design is only a tool to self express. And self expression is not something I can measure. 
I saw beautifully coloured drawings and completely monocromatic pencil sketches. The pencil sketches were all ‘self-justified’ even in those locations where colour was important. The 2 layers within may tell you a different story. I have seen students not able to afford good papers and good stationary. Should I have seen these 2 layers inside or was it not called for. It's is a tough world out there and I had to be conscious of these other facts which were built-in through the drawings on paper.
As I met more students - I started seeing deeper and more details emerged. Without bothering much if I was doing the right thing, I continued and made my conscience take over my thoughts.
Some had talent but the layers showed how the priorities change.
I was sitting here to judge if these students are making a good foundation for themselves. So what was going to be my approach? Shake it well and leave it shambles for him to repair on his own or shake it and the also guide the way to make it stronger. It was their another chance to correct themselves so I choose the later and concluded each students jury with suggestions and recommendations of what is good and what need improvement.
After reviewing work of 3-4 students I realised that time calculation had gone wrong somewhere. I am not going to be completing all 40 students in a day by giving equal justice to each and everyone's work. Finally each sketch, drawing is worth the discussion as the student has put in his hard work and best of his ability. It is very easy to make out where sincere efforts have been put in and where not. I feel the efforts should be valued and credited before everything else. Efforts are the basis for doing anything. Nothing can be achieved without efforts. In the sequence I would look at natural talent and skills at the last, because, if someone has it, it will show up in the efforts but if these still remain unused then the student he does not deserve the credit and his natural talent will be his last rescuer. 
I had to give marks for their work which in itself is a fallacy considering the subject has nothing right or wrong. 
It is alarming that boys are losing their sensitivity and sincerity even though they have the talent. I had to peel more layers for all the boys. At times reminding them of the efforts their parents must be taking to see them become a self reliant individual. 
The girls are doing better and better. At times simultaneously pursuing other full time activities like dance, sports to poetry. 
The exercises were well crafted and apt for the students to get to know the basic principles of design. One important thing was to sensitize them about importance of these exercises to become their default thought process and inherent part of their actions and work. These are not formulas students can mug-up or only remember by heart. They have to be inculcated as a part of their character and personality. While all the girls are very sincere in their efforts and can memorise and perfectly apply the process, very few are able to practice it. So all-in-all the outcome is same. Girls would be very sincere academically and score well, but, only those flourish and succeed who have imbibed the principles of design as a part of their thought process. 
Hence sincerity definitely gets the credit but it is not a sure evidence of the student having really understood the basic design principles. 
Suddenly I was posed with another challenge. It was reviewing work of girl who could not hear of speak. I was speechless in its literal sense. It started with a jolt, and then a surprise followed by curiosity and increased my level of anxiety. I asked why not? Architecture is not an art connected to language which itself is as abstract as the principles of design. In fact principles of architecture design are direct connection to the cognitive abilities of a brain to assimilate spatial information and environment. Language is in fact more abstract. It looks simple because it has been hammered from the very childhood and conditioned our brain and made us use it as a tool to think. For an architect language is only a tool to communicate and the relation ends. Visual design and these basic principles of design are the tools to think for an architect like language for everyone else. A real architect does not need to talk about what he does. It will demonstrate itself in its full glory through his work. It was indeed present and self realization in the set of assumptions and linear thinking process. I think it will take time for me to align to this diversion and restructure in the conventions. I have decided to stay in touch with this girl and would be ready to help and guide her. 

Speaking of language, basic design is the language for architects to think. 

One by one students came in and went. I remembered our days when it was so very important and curiosity was at the peak to know more about the external examiner. How is he? What does he ask? It would help in preparing for the answers? Was he tough, phadu or cool? I felt I should break ice with every student, put him at comfort and make him open to have a dialogue without inhibition. For some I was a friend, for some I was only a person seen more rainy days than them. And it used to work. Most students responded well and opened up. 
It is good that many have not developed an attitude of becoming defensive on being quizzed and cross examined. If they could give an explanation confidently, I was ok and appreciated his or her answer. Finally being able to express your thought is important. 
For some I asked them to create stories from their abstract model. I could see the twinkle in their eyes and sprint in their thoughts. We have to sensitize and teach students to dream and make their own stories. Stories remain for ages and objects rarely last.
I was sitting at a place for almost 8 hours with each student walking in with a portfolio full of his ideas, hard work and best of him for me to review. And with each student passing the feeling grew that I should not disappoint them. With every student a feeling of standing in front of a mirror grew successively. It is not that I am the best designer and a yardstick to compare the work of these young budding designers. It was important for me to stand there with no filters and personal preferences. I couldn't have seen their work with a coloured filter everything could have appeared coloured with my thoughts. I had to stand their naked to give justice to their hard work, thoughts and my comments should be of help and not merely a observation. 
Finally it was clear that I should not be simply rate their work, but it was my responsibility to tell them what can be done better and how things can be improved and for those who have got it well how to go deeper. It was also my duty to tell them how to make a choice because everything you do is a result of a choice you did some time and the choices make you the person you are. For some I told to choose tougher challenges because they had the ability but selected a simplest path. There is nothing wrong in selecting a simpler path but if this becomes a way of life then it is difficult to face tougher situations. 
All in all it was a great experience and I am eager for more.

The website of my college
http://www.bkps.edu/

Tuesday, March 26, 2013

The make-up generation.

It is always said. Beauty is skin deep. Which is why the efforts on making the cityscape better are called beautification. I give full marks to the politicians and the government for their apt use of English words. We really do skin deep work which at times is literally skin. A public toilet on Tilak road next the SP Collage gate is getting a makeover. It's getting a new skin of aluminium. Nothing done so far in the inside to keep it clean and hygenic to use. Why are we doing this?
This will make it match the nusence all around in the city of doing a make up to the old buildings and also to hide the absolutely badly designed structures, tasteless, shapeless and characterless.
People with genuine character high morals is difficult to find. The same is true with buildings these days. There is no honesty in architecture. It is only left as an arena for some institutional buildings for whom it is also a character code difficult to resist and at times force fitted.
Purity is missing. Who wants a good story. It's all about skin beauty and item numbers.
This is only story is not just of toilets but also of upcoming large urban infrastructure projects which lack the sense of purity of architecture and have completely missed an opportuinity of making and impact bring character to the city.
I feel very bad as we are we are wasting our natural resources. Material and manpower.

Tuesday, February 5, 2013

Delhi metro a moral booster.

Still remember those days 10 years ago when we were spending sleepless nights for getting the first six stations ready. Now it is a great experience. 10 years and we have a big city served by an efficient metro. I feel proud to have associated with this system. The sign which we designed to become a sort of light house or a marker. I designed it and now I use it. This feeling cannot be explained.
What I see around are very similar satisfied expressions on the face of each commuter. It feels they now own this system. They feel proud about it. And would also protect it from misuse
It is important that we give a good system to people and they will respect it.
I am sure every delhiet using the Metro will be happy.
It is important we design and build railways, public transport in the same spirit.
And it is not a question of money. People will pay in reasonable manner for a better experience and comfort.
This is how you experience contrast between my previous post on the experience at Hazarat Nizamuddin station against the one now in the Delhi metro.
All this is possible and we as Indians can do it. And can do it better.
I feel like I'm in HongKong.

The contrast

Just reached Nizamuddin railway station its 5:30 am. It's pouring outside. And a crowd of about 3 trains has just got down here. People with all sorts of luggage mostly nylon sacks, women with kids with them, some with big metal trunks, and some with stylish wheelers. All stuck at the gate. There is no covered link. There is a smart chaiwala who also has occupied some place below the covered parking.
There is no way I can step out without any protection from rain.
The station absolutely has no concourse.
What a contrast to an airport. The airport has more facilities only because people are ready to pay.
As I am writing this. One part of the rainwater channel gives in pouring all the water on to the staircase which was the only refuge for many people.
In all this mess the weighing machine is in its full glory glittering and attracting those who wish to know their weight.
Most people I see waiting here are from a lower middle class and even lower travelling all items packed in a cloth pouch.
On one side you have excess and other there is no scope of even demanding basic comfortable environments.
Rain seems to have stopped. Now I have a task to find a bus to the nearest metro station.